Tony's Pizza Cafe Sarver
Tony's Pizza Cafe Logo

Tony's Pizza Cafe

@

4.71542 reviews

Tony's Pizza Cafe is a vibrant pizzeria located at 117 Mulone Dr, Sarver, PA. The menu boasts a wide array of pizzas, sandwiches, and Italian specialties. Prices are budget-friendly, ranging from $10 to $20. The atmosphere is laid-back, making it a great spot for families and friends. Tony's offers takeout, delivery, and dine-in service, catering to various schedules.

The café also provides wheelchair access, ensuring everyone can enjoy a delicious meal. Whether it’s lunchtime or a casual dinner, the cafe is bustling with locals. Known for its excellent caramelized crust and generous toppings, Tony's has something for everyone, including options for vegetarians and gluten-sensitive diners.

About

Tony's Pizza Cafe has become a beloved staple in Sarver. This establishment blends delicious food with a welcoming atmosphere. Started by Andrea, the café focuses on bringing joy through food. His love for cooking shines through in each dish, making it special for every guest.

The café's history weaves into the fabric of this community. Tony's captures the essence of Sarver, where families gather, and memories are made over pizzas and desserts. As patrons walk in, they often feel like they're part of a big family. Meeting friends or making new ones happens seamlessly at Tony's, adding a memorable experience to every visit.

Get in Touch

117 Mulone Dr, Sarver, PA 16055, United States

Opening Hours

  • Monday Closed
  • Tuesday 11:00-20:30
  • Wednesday 11:00-20:30
  • Thursday 11:00-20:30
  • Friday 11:00-21:00
  • Saturday 11:00-21:00
  • Sunday Closed

Where to Visit

Get Directions

Customer Reviews

"Great pizza, so many options to choose from. Buffalo Chicken Mac n cheese Pizza was huge, the chicken broccoli Alfredo pizza was really good."

- isaac s.

"Andrea loves to create excellent meals for people. He has a passion for making people very happy with his mastery of culinary. Its my kind of real food."

- Charlie

"Phenomenal Pizza here. Chicken bacon, ranch, the sausage, and the Philly steak and cheese I've tried so far. In just 2 days! LOL You get it by the slice or you can get it by the pie. So good! Ran by a great group of staff here too. Very kind and accommodating. Highly recommend this place"

- Nathan O.

"These guys love their pizza. And make a massive variety of them. Highly recommend. Always delicious.Try the Buffalo Chicken Mac and Cheese. A whole meal in a slice!"

- C.J. S.

"Let me tell you...Tony's is a gem! The pizza crust is perfectly crispy with great texture. And the combination of toppings were unique and SO flavorful. I had one slice with white sauce, garlic, sliced tomatoes and spinach. The other slice was even better, it was a chicken Alfredo with the best tasting broccoli ever. I had a Bruscetta on some fabulous bread. Then finished with a delicious Canoli. Our server was so pleasant and helpful (as it was our first visit in years). We will definitely be going back often. Highly Recommended"

- Eric S.

"I mean, it was Tony's, it was phenomenal We got there a little late in the evening so we weren't able to do pizza by the slice because the selection was too limited So we just went ahead and got a couple sandwiches because we had been looking forward to Tony's for the entire day and we were on our way home from Butler... This place is always a go-to!"

- Matthew B.

"Hankering for a real good local place that is like NY and NJ? Look no further! Here you go. Trust me. I'm a pizza snob from NY, Long Island, and NJ, who loves New Haven Apizza!"

- Steven S.
Write a Review

Why Visit

Visiting Tony's Pizza Cafe is a must for pizza lovers and food enthusiasts alike. The diverse menu covers everything from traditional pies to unique gourmet options. Don't skip the Buffalo Chicken Mac n Cheese pizza; it's a local favorite and noted for its huge size and flavor. Other highlights include the Chicken Bacon Ranch and Philly Cheese Steak pizzas, which keep patrons coming back for more.

Lively dining is matched by quick service. Staff members are attentive and friendly, making sure every need is met. Lunchtimes can get busy, with peak hours seeing almost full capacity, but the wait is worth it. For a quieter experience, aim for late-night or early lunch visits.

Desserts shouldn't be overlooked either. The S'mores Pizza is a must-try, providing a sweet finish to your meal. Whether dropping by for a quick slice or a cozy dinner, Tony's offers a dining experience that feels warm and inviting, much like the community surrounding it.

Most Liked things

Patrons appreciate the remarkable pizza variety and the option to order by the slice. Both locals and visitors enjoy the cozy ambiance. Great service is a common highlight, with staff known for their friendliness. The unique toppings also receive numerous compliments, enhancing every pizza experience.

Most Disliked things

Some visitors note that busy peak times can lead to waits for a table. Others have mentioned limited late-night selections, especially on weekends. While the café offers numerous options, some patrons wish for even more vegetarian choices. Overall, though, any minor inconveniences are often overshadowed by the quality of the food.

FAQ

What menu items is Tony's Pizza Cafe famous for?

Tony's Pizza Cafe is known for its diverse pizza offerings. This includes New York style, gourmet, and large 16" pizzas. Don't miss their S'mores Pizza for dessert!

What are the restaurant's operating hours?

Tony's Pizza Cafe typically serves lunch and dinner. It's a popular spot for solo diners and groups, especially during lunch hours.

Is there parking available at Tony's Pizza Cafe?

Yes, there is free parking available both onsite and on the street. Parking is accessible for those with mobility needs.

What are the dining options at Tony's Pizza Cafe?

Tony's offers dine-in, takeout, and delivery options. It also features an accessible dining environment.

Are there vegetarian options on the menu?

Absolutely! Tony's Pizza Cafe includes various vegetarian dishes. They aim to cater to all dietary preferences.